Today I sat in on a class of 6th grade boys and
they were learning about holidays around the world. Since it was close to the 4th
of July they were studying Independence Day in the US. The students did a
reading about the history surrounding the 4th of July and the modern
day traditions. What surprised me was the students actually had substantial
background information about the celebration and US culture. Coincidently the
Argentine Independence day is the 9th of July so the teacher had the
students compare and contrast the Argentine and US celebration. What I found
interesting was that the students knew more about the US celebration then the
one in their own country. I spoke with the teacher about this and she explained
to me that the students are not taught patriotism in school. There is no pledge
of allegiance, national anthem, or classroom celebration for national holidays.
This was the first time it occurred to me that putting an emphasis on
patriotism in schools was not a universal practice but something unique to US
education. When I described to the student what students in the US have to do
to show respect and loyalty to their country, they found it strange and asked
me why we do that. Their question caught me off guard, as I had never really
considered the purpose of this practice in schools. Now that I am considering
it, I can’t decide if it is an important value to teach to students or not.
What do students really gain from doing things like reciting the pledge of allegiance
everyday?
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.