After
having spent several weeks at Colegio Highlands Los Fresnos, I have been able
to observe some great teachers and wonderful teaching exercises that I hope to
bring back to my classroom in the United States one day. Like I mentioned in my last
blog post, I have also noticed a lot of cultural differences between American
and Spanish schools, especially the long breaks that teachers and students have
during the day that I envy and that I think could really improve our
productivity in school. There are many things that I love about working in a
Spanish Catholic schools, but also many things that I wish I could change.
All in all, I
think that the school does a great job at meeting the needs of the typically
developing student. But, something that I began noticing my first day at school
and that I have continued to notice in all of my subsequent visits is that there
are students with special needs in all of the classrooms, but there is no
special education system in place nor training for the teachers for the
accommodation of these students. In the United States, there are a lot of
different models for special education and different kinds of programs for the
severity of the students’ disability. All students with documented
disabilities, whether in a substantially separate special education program or
in a full-inclusion classroom, are given an IEP or a 504 plan to help teachers
know how to best serve these individuals. Teachers are trained to work with
students with different disabilities and there are many different staff members,
such as therapists, to help streamline the education of these students. I’m not
saying that each student is always given the education that they should
receive, but there are a lot of systems in place to help ensure that they do.
Having
only ever seen this model of special education before, it shocks me that there
are students with a variety of special needs in the classes and that the
teachers have no way of handling it. On my first day at my pre-practicum, the
fourth grade teacher came up to me to tell me about her classroom and she
mentioned that there were a lot of students with special needs. She said that
they can make it really difficult to get things done during class. I was
surprised that she spoke so bluntly to me about this, but I assumed she just
wanted to fill me in. During class, however, I noticed her yelling at the
students for disrupting class or not paying attention and berating them for not
staying on task. This really bothered me, especially because I have worked with
students with special needs before and I know that this is one of the least
effective ways to get your message across.
I have now been to
Colegio Highlands five times and each subsequent time I have observed the same
kind of interactions between the teacher and her students. This past Thursday I
finally asked her about her experiences working with students with special
needs in the past, and she told me that she has had none. Although it didn’t
surprise me having observed her in class, it did because I couldn’t believe that
the school would place a teacher with no experience or training in a class with
so many students who have disabilities or who are being tested for them. I then
asked her what the special education system in the school is and she replied
that there isn’t one, and that there are no resources available for the
teachers.
From what I
understood from our conversation, these students have disabilities and are in
the general education classroom, but they have no action plans and set goals
for these students. I don’t know how typical this is, or if most students with
disabilities usually are in separate learning environments and do not attend
private schools such as this one, but it has definitely made my time at school
a little more difficult. This doesn’t make me dislike my school or the teachers
I am working with, but it has given me a lot of a chance to reflect on our
education system and it has made me appreciate it more. I am planning on
continuing to research the special education system here, but this is just
something that I have noticed that is probably the most significant difference
between teaching experiences in the U.S. and this one.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI am glad you are noticing both the positive and negative aspects of your practicum site and the education system in Madrid. It is unfortunate that a private school, which generally would have more resources, does not have adequate resources for students with special needs and their teachers. Were other teachers at the school more adept at meeting the needs of these students? Did you find out more about the special education system in Spain?
ReplyDelete